Cane Shrinkage, and an Urgent Case for the
Hand-shaping of Bassoon and Contrabassoon Reeds

Marvin P. Feinsmith


I. CANE SHRINKAGE AFTER SHAPING... from wet and dry.

A. Each and every piece of cane is different from the next piece.

B. Cane shrinks according to its own inherent nature and to the architectural stresses which occur during the drying process.

C. Shrinkage is most evident in the width of the reed, as the fibers in cane run lengthwise.

Contra Reed meas. 39mm blade, 32mm barrel1. The tipmost shrinkage
a. no bark
b. wider, therefore more fibers
c. furthest from the bark - deeper into the wall of the tube
d. largest size of fibers
e. fibers that are the least tight and dense.

Bassoon reed meas. 28mm blade and barrel2. The throat and tubeless shrinkage
a. bark intact
b. narrower, therefore less fibers
c. closest to the bark and outside wall of the tube
d. smallest size of fibers
e. fibers that are the most tight and dense.

II. THE FALLACY OF THE SHAPER

A. Each and every piece of cane, being different from the next piece, must shrink, while drying, each in its own individual and different manner according to its own inherent nature and to the architectural stresses of the shape.

1. All outside dimensions... are changed upon the total drying of the cane.
a. blade width... down to the
b. 1 st wire ... to the
c. 2nd wire ... to the
d. 3rd wire ... to the
e. back of the reed.

2. All inside dimensionsare changed upon the total drying of the cane, after wiring.
a. "bore", or area inside of the blade
b. "bore", or area of the blade funneling into the tube
c. "bore" of the tube
d. "inner spaces", or configurations and "shapes" of these inside areas.

B. "Pulls"... When any single dimension changes, it "pulls", or affects the parts of another dimension, or set of dimensions, as the total architecture is related and exists as one flow of sequences - one system.

C. The shaper is "unable" to understand, and thereby, cannot compensate for these most crucial sequential changes which occur within the dynamics of cane in its drying process.

D. Shaping wet, to the final shape on a shaper guarantees a new, incorrect shape upon drying and shrinking, either before or after wiring, due to the FALLACY OF THE SHAPER.



III. EXAMPLES OF SHRINKAGE DURING THE VARIOUS STAGES

CONTRABASSOON BASSOON

1. Starting with the following shape, when dry...

 Contrabassoon    Bassoon
 19mm  Tip  14.5mm
 11.75  lst wire  10
 11.25  2nd wire  9.5
 11.25  Back  9.5

2. After soaking 8 hours, when wet...

Contrabassoon     Bassoon
 20mm  Tip  15.3mm
 12.35  lst wire  10.4
 11.60  2nd wire  9.8
 11.60  Back  9.8

3. After drying 48 hours, completely dry... return to normal

 Contrabassoon    Bassoon
 19mm  Tip  14.5mm
 11.75  lst wire  10
 11.25  2nd wire  9.5
 11.25  Back  9.5

4. Immediately after wiring, when wet

 Contrabassoon    Bassoon
 20mm  Tip  15.1
 11.6 wire
10.75
 lst wire  10. wire
9.2
 9.6  2nd wire  8.8
 8.9  Back  8.75

5. After drying 24 hours, not tightening wires
 Contrabassoon    Bassoon
 19mm  Tip  14.5mm
 10.5
9.75
 lst wire  9.85
9.
 9.  2nd wire  8.5
 8.5  Back  8.3

6. After drying 24 hours, tightening wires

 Contrabassoon    Bassoon
 19mm  Tip  14.5mm
10.5
9.6
 lst wire 9.7
8.9
 8.7  2nd wire  8.25
 8.3  Back  8.10

IV. PROCEDURES FOR HAND-SHAPING OF REEDS...

A. Rough-shape, wet...
after 6-8 hours soaking of profiled cane (Preferably hand-profiled, but machine is passable) leaving the shape at least 20% too wide, to allow for shrinkage.

Hand-shaping figure1. Technique... with knife sharpened on one side only (to make a leading edge), chip away on the shape (folded over) from tip to rear of reed. i.e.: hold reed in left hand (palm upwards towards the face) by the tip area between thumb and index finger with base of reed resting on palm of thumb. Place right thumb on base of reed and draw knife, with right hand, in chipping motions towards you. Wrap base of reed 3 or 4 turns with very thin cotton thread, knot, and let dry.


B. Drying... at least 48 hours in the open, not enclosed in a drawer, or case, or box. Best is on a glass plate, or saucer.

C. Fine-shape, dry ... to finished dimensions, after total drying of at least 48 hours.

1. Technique ... use progressively finer tools, from No. 0 files, to No. 1; to knife; back to files; to diamond file; to finally 320 or 400 sandpaper wrapped around a file or 1/4 inch india
stone , fine (preferred over sandpaper), holding the reed as in

A-1 above. Always check dimensions with micrometer for ultra precision while you are working.

2. Technique... file from Ist wire to tip, and from 1st wire to rear holding the reed as in A- I above, but reverse the left hand hold, to file from 1st wire to rear. Blend in from both directions with india stone, or use sandpaper wrapped around a file.

3. Technique... be certain that sides are exactly at right angles to the cane and that there is no slippage or overlapping of the blades - either near the tip, on the blade, or on the tube (your hold of the reed is most crucial for stability and non- slippage... and for working of the sides evenly.)


D. Discard... any shape that is not on the measurement 100 % with the micrometer. I allow for no plus or minus.

E. Time Element for A. Rough-shape, wet 1 to 2 minutes

for B. Fine-shape, dry 3 to 5 minutes

F. Questions... for further information, please write me:

c/o Israel Philharmonic Orchestra

Mann Auditorium. P.O.B. 11292
TEL AVIV, ISRAEL

I promise an answer.

About the writer...

Bassoon and contrabassoon with the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra, Marvin Feinsmith is a New
York City native and a graduate of the Mozarteum of Salzburg, the Juilliard and the Manhattan
School of Music with a Masters degree. He has also done graduate work towards a Ph.D. at New York University and at the University of Colorado.

Feinsmith has played as Principal Bassoon with the Juilliard School and Manhattan School orchestras, the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra, the Mozarteum of Salzburg, the Brooklyn Philharmonia, the Symphony of The Air, the Little Orchestra Society, and Co-Principal Bassoon with the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra under Leonard Bernstein and Zubin Mehta. He was Solo Bassoon in 1972 for the "Mass" under the direction of Leonard Bernstein, the same year he joined the Denver Symphony Orchestra, as Assistant Principal Bassoon, where he has played for 13 years.

As a composer, Mr. Feinsmith has written No'ach, a commissioned work by the Piccolo Society for mezzo soprano voice, piccolo and alto flute, harp and percussion. No'ach was premiered in Carnegie Recital Hall on December 5, 1984, to a fine review by the New York Times, and several notices in the Denver newspapers. He has also written two Hebraic studies for bassoon alone, published by Music for Wind Instruments.

Mr. Feinsmith is presently playing contrabassoon and bassoon with the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra at the invitation of Maestro Zubin Mehta.


Table of Contents